OTTAWA: A women’s rights organization says the House of Commons justice committee has removed crucial provisions from a private member’s bill aimed at protecting women and children experiencing domestic violence. However, the MP who introduced the bill stated that the Minister of Justice has agreed to study the issue in greater depth.
Liberal MP Lisa Hepfner introduced Bill C-223 to amend the Divorce Act and restrict claims of “parental alienation”—the allegation that one parent is turning a child against the other. The National Association of Women and the Law (NAWL) alleges that the committee stripped the core provisions regarding parental alienation from the bill.
Criticism from Advocacy Group
In a statement, Suzanne Zaccour, NAWL’s director of legal affairs, said the government and committee members missed an opportunity to protect women and children from harmful parental alienation claims. She noted that mothers who report domestic abuse are frequently penalized and separated from their children for months or even years.
Zaccour pointed out that this argument is widely used in courts to cast doubt on domestic abuse allegations by suggesting a child’s fear of their father is caused by the mother’s manipulation. She added that the committee did not even hear testimony from survivors and should have proposed amendments rather than removing the provisions entirely.
Justice Minister Agrees to Further Study
In an interview on Wednesday, MP Lisa Hepfner said Justice Minister Sean Fraser has personally assured her that he will study the matter more deeply. The Minister also indicated that the Department of Justice is prepared to examine flaws in the family law system and how such concepts are being misused.
While acknowledging that the bill did not achieve everything she had hoped for, Hepfner emphasized that it still secures major gains. Chief among them is the removal of the “friendly parent rule” in divorce cases—a provision that effectively forced mothers to support a child’s relationship with the other parent, even when they feared the child was unsafe with them.
Suzanne Zaccour agreed that eliminating the friendly parent rule will improve child safety in divorce proceedings. She noted that mothers were previously caught in a catch-22: stating that a father was dangerous led to accusations of failing to support the parent-child relationship, while supporting the relationship made their safety concerns appear less credible. Although the House committee has completed its review and amendments, the bill must still pass through further parliamentary stages, including the Senate, before becoming law.
